Повідомити • Board Game Arena

Усі звіти

Звіти по грі City of the Big Shoulders

#23292: "Price Protection should be once per Decade and optional"

open: Розробники ще не відтворили цю помилку

Про що цей звіт?

City of the Big Shoulders #109126807

Що трапилося? Будь ласка, виберіть нижче

Правила: правило гри не дотримано

Що трапилося? Будь ласка, виберіть нижче

Правила: правило гри не дотримано

Будь ласка, перевірте, чи вже є звіт на цю тему

Якщо це так, будь ласка, ПРОГОЛОСУЙТЕ за цей звіт. Звіти з найбільшою кількістю голосів розглядатимуть У ПЕРШУ ЧЕРГУ!

#	Status	Votes	Game	Type	Title	Last update

Детальний опис

Історія звітів

27 Aug 2020 23:51 • Joseph2302 • Розробники ще не відтворили цю помилку:

Company owner should be given option on whether or not to use this tile
And it shouldn't work for the whole decade, as that is too powerful

28 Aug 2020 22:43 • mitcharf • Розробники ще не відтворили цю помилку:

I agree that it is a powerful capital asset, but it is not intended to work just once per decade. The designer clarified this on BGG here:
boardgamegeek.com/thread/2256464/article/32703243#32703243

In terms of it being optional rather than mandatory, I'm trying to think of a case where I would NOT want to have my stock price protected from dropping. If there are legitimate cases where that would be of possible benefit, then it's worth pursuing that with the game designer, to see what he thinks. Otherwise it seems like it would needlessly delay the game if a player had to be prompted every time to see if they wanted to use it (especially since it can be used multiple times per decade)

29 Aug 2020 00:57 • arcadized • Розробники ще не відтворили цю помилку:

A player in that game asked the designer and the designer agrees this is bugged here:

www.boardgamegeek.com/thread/2493015/capital-asset-price-protection

29 Aug 2020 01:00 • arcadized • Розробники ще не відтворили цю помилку:

@mitcharf

Did you even read the link you posted? When I go there I see the designer has edited it to reflect the current version of the rules:

boardgamegeek.com/thread/2256464/article/32703243#32703243

also see the thread I posted:

www.boardgamegeek.com/thread/2493015/capital-asset-price-protection

IF you tool tip over the asset in BGA, you can see BGA is using the current version of the rules. this is a bug and the designer agrees

29 Aug 2020 05:00 • mitcharf • Розробники ще не відтворили цю помилку:

I've been participating in both of those threads. When I posted my comment here in the bug, it was before the designer had stayed that this was a change for the second edition. I was just coming here now to mention that I was mistaken in my previous comment, but I see you've beaten me to it.

Hopefully you also saw that I asked the designer about whether you can choose when to use this asset, and he replied that you do get to choose.

29 Aug 2020 16:52 • arcadized • Розробники ще не відтворили цю помилку:

Ah, I see now. Sorry, looks like it was a timing issue. Didn't realize that was your thread, I don't use BGG very much. Thanks for coming back to correct the information here.

29 Aug 2020 17:18 • mitcharf • Розробники ще не відтворили цю помилку:

No problem. We all want the same thing here -- for the BGA version to implement the rules correctly. :)

30 Aug 2020 03:49 • ggohierroy • Розробники ще не відтворили цю помилку:

Hey, so this adaptation was implemented when the 2nd edition rules were still being worked on, and the latest information I had at that time was that Price Protection was a passive ability that could be used multiple times in the same decade.

Now, I understand this has changed with the 2nd edition, but it wouldn't be easy to change with the implementation because it means multiple actions can be interrupted and switch to the player holding price protection because they now have a decision to make. This changes the flow of the game significantly, and in asynchronous games, this also has a big impact.

Just so you know, I have no intention of changing this in the short term because of those reasons. I'll leave it open for visibility.

12 Sep 2020 04:28 • alexsim • Розробники ще не відтворили цю помилку:

I think it would be reasonable to trigger the Asset automatically the first time it could be used. I can see where there would be edge cases where you wouldn't want it used, but I think the loss from automatically applying it would be less of a problem than letting it work all the time.

14 Sep 2020 02:02 • ggohierroy • Розробники ще не відтворили цю помилку:

@alexsim

Good idea, but knowing this, a player would use this knowledge to their advantage, making this capital asset go from amazing, to complete shit.

4 Dec 2020 22:51 • Neramoor • Розробники ще не відтворили цю помилку:

Bug appeared in real time game. Price protection not exhausting during stock phase
imgur.com/a/kvZYdhh

3 Jan 2021 00:19 • Nickelz • Розробники ще не відтворили цю помилку:

Neramoor, the company that lost 3 steps is not the same as the company with the asset.

18 Jan 2021 13:48 • attagamer • Розробники ще не відтворили цю помилку:

The designer of the game has published a rewording of the capital asset effect on BGG:
boardgamegeek.com/thread/2256464/article/35690787#35690787

I believe the BGA implementation is in accordance with this new/clarified rule.

19 Jan 2021 08:53 • attagamer • Розробники ще не відтворили цю помилку:

Ooops, sorry! I meant that the BGA implementation is in accordance with the v1 rules.

Note the inconsistence between the behaviour (v1) and the tip text when hovering over the capital asset: the latter reflects the v2 rules!

The v2 rules have changed the ability of the capital asset, and the BGA implementation has thus become wrong.

Clarification by Mr Chandler (author) here: boardgamegeek.com/thread/2256464/article/35690787#35690787

He says: "In the Second Edition, this rule has changed to be a "ONCE PER DECADE" ability. It is no longer a passive ability."

Do not forget to grey out the capital asset once used.

Thank you for your time!

18 Apr 2021 20:28 • MrGeorge • Розробники ще не відтворили цю помилку:

So, to clarify, how do we use this asset to prevent the stock price from dropping during the stock phase?

22 Apr 2021 03:10 • JohnOrigan • Розробники ще не відтворили цю помилку:

Price protection is currently always enable (passive ability).

To follow the rules, it should protect only once (not implemented)

Додайте що-небудь до цього відгуку

Будь ласка, додайте тут усе, на вашу думку, важливе, що дозволить нам відтворити вашу помилку чи ліпше зрозуміти вашу пропозицію:

ID іншого столу / ходу
F5 вирішило проблему?
Чи виникає проблема періодично? Щоразу? Випадково?
If you have a screenshot of this bug (good practice), you can use a picture hosting service of your choice (snipboard.io for example) to upload it and copy/paste the link here.

Скасувати Оновити звіт

#23292: "Price Protection should be once per Decade and optional"

Про що цей звіт?

Що трапилося? Будь ласка, виберіть нижче

Що трапилося? Будь ласка, виберіть нижче

Будь ласка, перевірте, чи вже є звіт на цю тему

Детальний опис

Історія звітів

Додайте що-небудь до цього відгуку

Змінити стан звіту на:

Допомога

Внесок

Навігація

Стежте за нами